An Honest Popup for a Company That Handles Your Money

Timeline
2 weeks
Role
Frontend engineer and designer
Team
Lead product designer
Chief marketing officer
Marketing specialist
Performance marketing manager

CoinFlip operates thousands of Bitcoin ATMs across the world. As part of a new initiative, the marketing team wanted to use our website welcome popup to boost account signups.

Starting point

Marketing originally proposed a small modification to our existing newsletter popup: after a visitor submitted their email, a new tab would open and bring them to our crypto dashboard signup page. Additionally, the popup would open on every visit until signup.

New direction

I was originally brought on to the project to implement changes in code, but I noticed we were in deceptive pattern territory, so I suggested creating a new popup where the account signup ask is explicit. Otherwise, if the old newsletter popup took people to the signup page, at best they would be confused, and at worst they would feel deceived that the action didn’t match the button’s promise.

Marketing agreed and prototyped a new popup. The following walks through how I reshaped that first design to improve visual impact and increase trust.

The popup that kept popping up

I was worried that opening the popup on every visit would train visitors to close it without reading and get in the way of browsing, so I explored the following alternatives:

  • Show the popup once. Reduces annoyance, but gives up future opportunity to claim the discount.
  • Exponential backoff. Show it on first visit, then a few days later, couple weeks, couple months. But there’s no way to claim the discount in between.
  • Persistent floating button. The popup shows once, then a “Get 20% off” button appears on every visit after the visitor closes it.

I presented these ideas to the marketing team while pushing for the floating button. This approach is beneficial because it keeps the ability to get the discount on future visits, and visitors won’t be interrupted by seeing the popup all the time. Marketing was on board with the idea and wanted to move forward with it.

Analytics and impact

The marketing team ran an A/B test with our old popup and the new one. It’s hard to make a direct comparison because the old popup simply asked for an email, whereas the new one requires an account signup.

Full account creations came in at two-thirds the volume of the one-field email capture.

Of the total conversions, 40% were created accounts and 60% were newsletter signups. In other words, the new popup drove two-thirds as many conversions as the old one, despite the bigger ask. Happy with the tradeoff, the marketing team considered it a success.

Share of total signups
40%
New popup (account signups)
60%
Old popup (newsletter signups)

Takeaways

Marketing’s original ideas would have boosted signups while misleading people. By treating their spec as a goal rather than a plan I was able to get them the signups wanted with an ask visitors could trust.