Field Notes (Various App UX Critiques)

|

5 minute read

The following is a collection of UX critiques from apps I use: the issue, the rationale, and a possible fix.

Google Maps

Issue: I often used Starred Locations for when I stay in a hotel or need to mark something important. However, when making a location search, such as for nearby references, the starred pins disappear. This is an issue because I usually want to see how far away a restaurant is from where I’m staying.

Rationale: This was likely done to declutter the UI when there are a lot of search result pins.

Possible fix: The starred location pin could be dimmed or translucent so that it’s still present but not as prominent.

Gmail Sidebar Preventing Swipe Back

Issue: When reading an email in Gmail, it’s convenient to be able to swipe right and get back to your inbox. However, Gmail also uses a sidebar menu that is activated by swiping right. When this happens, it’s not possible to get back to your inbox by swiping, even if the sidebar is closed.

Rationale: This was probably a bug, but demonstrates how easily a user flow can be disrupted by a small change.

Possible fix: only allow the sidebar to be opened when in your full inbox.

Airbnb

Issue: Airbnb messages often contain details such as the wifi password. However, you have to copy the entire message as there is no option to select portions. As such, there is no easy way to extract what you need.

Rationale: A context menu opens when the message is expanded, which contains a lot of useful options. It’s not possible to add text highlighting with the tap and hold behaviour.

Possible fix: Add and option in the context menu to select specific parts of the message.